Project Description

Fly By Night Cookie Company is another one of those magical finds in the charming village of Fair Haven. A unique cookie and pastry shop located in a funky house down Fancher Avenue near Little Sodus Bay. You can walk there from the village or go there by car or bike.

You’ll find a spell-binding assortment of interesting cookies, pies, cakes and pastries at the Fly By Night Cookie Company. They tell us that there are 65 varieties of homemade cookies in the store!

Grab a bag and wander through this fun shop full of enchanting miniatures and displays that are guaranteed to get a “WOW” from your kids. All of the wonderful concoctions here are made in the Old World tradition from “scratch” with real eggs, butter, and fresh fruit from local farms. No chemicals or preservatives.

And oh, you can sit out on the porch too and enjoy a private brunch or high tea.

We highly recommend the Fly By Night Cookie Company to all of our seasonal and visiting boaters.

Contact Information


14541 Fancher Avenue
Fair Haven, N.Y. 13064


(315) 947-5588